About This Archive | DCHAS-L 2005 Index | DCHAS-L Yearly Index | DCHAS-L Home Page
I was startled to find the following comments in promo e-mail I
received for a BBC podcast I listen to regularly. The topic of the
podcast ("In Our Time") was asteroids and comets, so this seemed a
rather spurious tangent from the subject. I wonder how the Division
membership reacts to it?
My memory of freshman chemistry is that sniffing the fumes from the
bubbling sulphuric acid over the bunsen burner was that an experience
led to me resolving to avoid chemistry classes in the future...
- Ralph
From: melvyn-bragg**At_Symbol_Here**lists.bbc.co.uk
Subject: Melvyn Bragg's In Our Time Newsletter - 03/11/2005
Date: November 3, 2005 3:21:25 PM EST
Further back on the education chain, though, the worry is that young
people are not being attracted to chemistry because of the draconian
application of Health and Safety rules. The sort of experiments that
we did in labs with Bunsen burners and mixing things and hoping for
bangs and liking to see fermentation and bubbling and grizzling, has
now been banned. A teacher stands behind a glass screen and
demonstrates. In other words, all the three of them agreed, it seems
to be no fun at all for students who are peeling away from chemistry
en masse. The worry is not only that fewer students are taking up
chemistry, but that even those who are taking it up cannot be hands
on and, therefore, cannot begin to be innovative at the start of
their careers. There was worry that this would lead to a drop off of
real interest in pushing chemistry forward into areas where it is now
so important, to do with research into fuels into the atmosphere and
so on.
It seems that, again and again, when we bandage people against
reality we save some things but seem to lose at least as much and
perhaps far more important things. As this country has been so
fantastically effective in its studies of chemistry over the past two
centuries, it would be a pity if over-fierce regulation were to crush
the life out of it, which seems to be the case.