Neal - While I am strongly in favor of electronic balloting and appreciate your request for input prior to the meeting in Philadelphia, it seems to me that a request to the ListServe would skew the results towards those who are more inclined to support electronic balloting; after all, we've all chosen to sign up to participate in this electronic discussion. Just something else to think about. Looking forward to seeing you in Philadelphia! Tony ______________________________ Anthony M. Noce, CHMM Supervising Chemist MWH Americas, Inc. 10 Airline Drive, Suite 200 Albany, New York 12205 Direct Dial (518) 640-6009 Office Phone (518) 640-6010 Fax (518) 640-6006 Cell (518) 369-6403 e-Mail Anthony.M.Noce**At_Symbol_Here**mwhglobal.com Neal Langerman
cc: Sent by: DCHAS-L Subject: [DCHAS-L] E-ballot Discussion List 08/12/2004 06:01 PM Please respond to Neal Langerman CHAS Members - As current Chair, I need your input, fast on electronic ballotting. The issue will be put before ACS Council in Philly in 14 days. The issue is whether ACS (and DivCHAS) should use e-ballots for all elections. ACS has prepared a list of FAQs, as follows ... If you have feelings either way, please let me know by 8/17 - I leave for the east on 8/18 and want to have some idea about your feelings before the DivCHAS Executive meeting. Thanks Neal Langerman - Chair, DivCHAS, 2004 Frequently Asked Questions about e-Balloting If the petition before Council passes, when will e-balloting be used in an ACS National Election? The proposal to vote over the Internet would go on the 2004 national election ballot. If approved by membership, e-balloting could be used for the 2005 national election. Who will develop the e-balloting technology and conduct the presidential elections? ACS will use an experienced external vendor to develop the technology and conduct the election. There are several well-qualified vendors in this industry with a record of accomplishment in using e-balloting for association elections. Will voting over the Internet discourage members who are more comfortable voting by mail? Elections will be conducted via "hybrid" methods, combining mail and Internet voting. Members will therefore have a choice, voting either by the mail ballot or over the Internet. How will e-balloting prevent fraudulent balloting? Before each election, the vendor will generate a unique PIN (Personal Identification Number) for each voting member. The PIN will be used to identify the member to the system and to resolve any issues with respect to double voting. The PIN can only be used once. What happens if a member votes twice, once over the Internet and again through the mail? A member's mail ballot will have the same PIN as the e-ballot so that any duplicate vote would be detected and invalidated before votes are tallied. Is my vote confidential? Will the vendor (or ACS) be able to see how I voted? Before tallying the votes, the vendor breaks the association between each PIN and that member's vote. ACS will not know for whom a member voted, only what the balloting results are. What happens if I do not receive my ballot package in the first place? The procedures will be similar to what occurs now. The member contacts ACS for a new package and the vendor issues a replacement. How will a vendor archive the balloting results without compromising anonymity? The vendor, as the trusted authority conducting the election, will keep a record of the election. N&E, with CPC concurrence, would specify what information the vendor should retain. By agreement, the vendor would be able to audit the election and recreate the results, but ACS would only be able to see the results. Will e-balloting cause any delays in getting the election results? The vendor tallies the election results after the election period closes, as is done now. The vendor would then count the mail votes and merge them with the Internet votes (discounting double voting). The process would not take any longer than the current process. What security methods do vendors use to prevent a hacker from disrupting an election? Vendors use multiple, industry-standard methods to "harden" their sites. Vendors use a secure facility with controlled and monitored access, and protect the network infrastructure with redundancy and scalability. The vendors use state-of-the-art firewall and intrusion detection software. How would the vendor know that someone is a valid member of the ACS? ACS would provide the vendor with the list of current members eligible to vote, as is done now with the current election procedure. What would be the long-term benefits to the Society of voting online rather than continuing to use the mail balloting procedures? ACS is committed to providing products and services through the Internet. The ACS members are enthusiastically using these new services. Electronic balloting is the direction that our members are asking us to go. Will the society save money through e-balloting? Initially, hybrid elections using both mail and electronic balloting would cost a little more. If e-balloting were to become the preferred method of voting (which is likely), the cost savings could be large because of reduced postage and handling costs. Will voter turnout increase through e-balloting? Many organizations, including associations and ACS divisions, have experienced an increase in member participation.
Previous post | Top of Page | Next post