Safety Emporium for all your lab and safety needs

Energy Units

Glossary Index

EPCRA

MSDS Topics	Free Sites	FAQ's	Regulations	Glossary	Software	Suppliers
	Books	Forum	Poll	Fun stuff	Quiz	Store
Understand your MSDS with the MS-Demystifier				Search ALL our MSDS info

Engineering Controls

Definition

Engineering controls eliminate or reduce exposure to a chemical or physical hazard through the use or substitution of engineered machinery or equipment. Examples include self-capping syringe needles, ventilation systems such as a fume hood, sound-dampening materials to reduce noise levels, safety interlocks, and radiation shielding.

Additional Info

When substitution of hazardous chemicals or processes is simply not possible, additional measures to control employee exposure need to be taken. While personal protective equipment (PPE) such as respirators can help protect an individual from a hazardous material, engineering controls protect all workers by reducing or eliminating the hazard. For example, someone who is spray-painting can wear a respirator to avoid inhaling toxic fumes, but nearby workers without any respiratory protection will be exposed. Through the use of proper local exhaust ventilation everyone can be protected. In fact, the OSHA standard on Air Contaminants, 29 CFR 1910.1000, requires the use of either engineering or administrative controls if any such controls are feasible:

Get your corrosion-resistant polyethylene acid storage cabinets from Safety Emporium.

"...administrative or engineering controls must first be determined and implemented whenever feasible. When such controls are not feasible to achieve full compliance, protective equipment or any other protective measures shall be used to keep the exposure of employees to air contaminants within the limits prescribed in this section. Any equipment and/or technical measures used for this purpose must be approved for each particular use by a competent industrial hygienist or other technically qualified person. Whenever respirators are used, their use shall comply with 1910.134.

Note: In certain circumstances, administrative controls can be successful in controlling employee exposure to contaminants; e.g., maintenance operations involving toxic substances can sometimes be performed at night in the absence of the usual production staff (but not to comply with the PEL of OSHA-regulated carcinogens).

This does not mean that engineering and other types of controls (including PPE) are mutually exclusive. Employers may need to use multiple types of controls to prevent employee overexposure. Also note that the degree to which engineering controls are required depends on the particular standard. For example, 29 CFR 1910.95(b)(1) Occupational Noise Exposure, allows employers to rely on personal protective equipment (PPE) and a hearing conservation program rather than engineering and/or administrative controls if hearing protectors will effectively reduce the noise hazard to acceptable levels.

Get your PPE training handbooks, posters and videos at Safety Emporium.

OSHA considers economic feasibility to be a major issue with engineering controls. Requirements that would threaten the economic viability of an entire industry cannot be considered economically feasible under the OSH Act. OSHA may permit PPE in lieu of engineering controls (at least until engineering controls become a less significant burden for the company) when all of the following apply: If significant reconstruction of a single establishment involving a capital expenditure which would seriously jeopardize the financial condition of the company is the only method whereby the employer could achieve effective engineering controls; If there are no feasible administrative or work practice controls; and If adequate personal protective equipment or devices are available.

When employers complain that implementation of engineering controls will present an unbearable economic burden, they must present evidence that addresses the reasonableness of the estimated costs of engineering or administrative controls. This includes installation, maintenance, and lost productivity, as well as their progress compared to their industry peers. The evidence may also include the relative costs of engineering or administrative controls versus PPE.

In those limited situations where there are no feasible engineering or administrative controls, full abatement can be allowed by PPE.

Books Available

• "Safety Engineering: Principles and Practices", Hardcover, 544 pages, 2004. Estimated price $109.00. Info and/or order.
• "Safety and Health for Engineers", Hardcover, 758 pages, 2005. Estimated price $82.60. Info and/or order.
• "Occupational Ergonomics: Engineering and Administrative Controls (Principles and Applications in Engineering, 14)", Hardcover, 627 pages, 2003. Estimated price $107.58. Info and/or order.
• "Hazard Communication Made Easy: A Checklist Approach to OSHA Compliance", Paperback, 310 page, 2000. Estimated price: $94.00. Info and/or order.
• "Control Systems Engineering, 5th Ed", Hardcover, 880 pages, 2007. Estimated price: $129.02. Info and/or order.

MSDS Relevance

The preferred methods for reducing chemical exposure, in order of general effectiveness, are:
1. Substitution of less hazardous materials or processes.
2. Engineering controls
3. Administrative controls
4. Personal protective equipment (PPE)

Engineering controls may receive specific mention on MSDS's. For example, when a material has a low PEL, there may be a section explicitly labeled "Ventilation requirements". Specific machinery may be recommended - or perhaps specifically discouraged. For example, ductless recirculating laboratory hoods might not provide sufficient protection from certain highly toxic materials; in these cases a properly vented fume hood (perhaps outfitted with a scrubber) would be required.

Two of the most common engineering controls found on an MSDS are local exhaust and general ventilation. There are dozens of types of engineering controls.

Further Reading Hazard Prevention and Control at OSHA. Part of a very useful Safety & Health Management System e-Tool. Get an idea for the diversity and scope of engineering controls by examining these engineering control diagrams for lead smelters at OSHA. One of NIOSH's major programs is engineering controls. View the Program Description and then follow the links for much more information. The National Science Teachers Association offers a free download, "Safer Science: Building Safety with Engineering Controls" (free registration required). The Hazard Controls section of the Chemical Hygiene Plan at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory includes a discussion titled "Selection and Use of Engineering Controls". See also: administrative controls, fume hoods, respirators, personal protective equipment (PPE), ventilation. Additional definitions from Google and OneLook.

When engineering controls aren't enough, consider lockout devices like these from Safety Emporium.

Disclaimer: The information contained herein is believed to be true and accurate, however ILPI makes no guarantees concerning the veracity of any statement. Use of any information on this page is at the reader's own risk. ILPI strongly encourages the reader to consult the appropriate local, state and federal agencies concerning the matters discussed herein.